Angie and Toby are recurring guests who have appeared on the show at least 4 times between 2004 and 2005.
Angie feared that her husband Toby was cheating on her and got several women pregnant. Angie said he admitted to cheating three times. When Maury asked why she stayed with him, Angie said "Because I love him." Maury asked her if she would still stay with him if he's still cheating and Angie said "No, I can't."
Prior to the show's taping, Toby was given a lie detector test when he stopped it and decided to come clean and reveal a secret that Maury described as "So shocking, so devastating, it left us speechless". A prerecorded tape was shown of Toby confessing to Angie that he got her sister Kerena pregnant, which lead her to walking backstage sobbing and screaming. Maury asked Toby what happened to the pregnancy and he said that Kerena went to the hospital and got a "shot where you can't get pregnant". Toby also admitted that he cheated with eight more women.
Sometime between 2004 and Feb. 3, 2005, Toby and Angie appeared on the show 2 times, for unknown reasons, probably due to Toby's cheating. On February 3, 2005, Toby and Angie appeared on the Maury Show for a 4th time, this time for a paternity test for their 2 week old son. Toby was the father. Toby and Angie have appeared on the show since then.